My Good Eats Review: CookShop, NYC

COOKSHOP, NYC

October 2014

Rating: 1 (not edible) to 5 (food heaven!): A Solid 4 on Food!  A lack-luster 2 on service (however at a later visit, service up their game to a solid 4 as well!)

I was pleasantly surprised by how delicious our lunch was! No seriously, I had a salad and it was freaking amazing!  Came here on a Friday for lunch and OMG, what a crowd… look to the left, tourist just finishing sights at the Highline… look to the right, industry locals of the artsy… well.. thank goodness for OpenTable!  Made a reservation for 12:45 and was surprised we were seated only 10 mins after our reservation.  (Hint: they have bar seatings for those flying solo)! Hostess was nice & preppy.

Amazing Hudson Chicken Salad, CookShop NYC
Amazing Hudson Chicken Salad, CookShop NYC

Decor:  modern, festive for Fall.. I would recommend changing those red leather bench to a tufted black leather for more ‘oomph’..  right now it looks outta place like a diner..esque…  open kitchen, for those wishing to watch how their food is being prepare.. didn’t like that ‘restaurant kitchen smell’ on my clothes though..  the unisex WC is clean, but a bit dark.. not sure why.. still, no lines!

Food: free sourdough bread (when offered, always say yes!) w butter.. ok, we skipped the starters bc we worker bees had only 1hr for lunch.  Lunch date had the Skirt Steak… nothing to brag about.. just steak.
Me – I had this amazingly awesome seared Chicken breast over kale/dried cranberries/walnuts – I literally licked  the plate… the chicken was moist, tender and the skin was seared & full of flavors.

Nothing to brag about Skirt Steak, Cookshop NYC
Nothing to brag about Skirt Steak, Cookshop NYC

Dessert: apple crisp (fried pastry with caramelized  apples, and ice cream), pumpkin bread w pumpkin ice cream (fried pumpkin doughnuts!)

Overall it was a great meal.  I will be returning to try other treats on the menu.. just maybe not during touristy hours… and yes, why 3 stars?

The food itself is 4 stars!!  I took off 1 star for my waitress’ disappearing act… another waitress had to give us the dessert menu & couldn’t locate her when we wanted our check.. took over 15-20mins before we grabbed another waitress to just pay for our bill. The other minus – not offering us a table away from the outdoor seating – I asked if we could take the other table away from the gusting cold wind.. ‘sorry, that table is being transform for a party of 6’.  Really? We would be half way done by the time ur party of 6 all showed up… seriously, they did. We got our bill as they sat down.

HAPPY FEASTING! 

What are you thinking?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s